Nemanja Matic signed a new contract in the summer and it looked like a smart decision from Manchester United.
So it has been disappointing to see the way his form has trailed off this season.
The warning signs were there back against Spurs in the 6-1 defeat. He was hooked at half-time with United 4-1 down. The defensive protection he is usually so good at giving to the backline no longer looked impenetrate.
This may have given Solskjaer reason to doubt him too, because Matic has struggled to get a regular run of games.
While this is no doubt a factor behind his flimsy form, he is not doing much with the chances he does get.

He looked off the pace in Leipzig and it was an error to start him (a predictable one).
It was less of a risk to start him against Sheffield United, and Solskjaer was able to leave Bramall Lane with three points.
Question marks over Matic remain however.
While United were dominant for spells, Paul Pogba was a far bigger influence on the midfield battle than Matic was.
From a defensive standpoint, Matic failed to win a single tackle, or make a single interception.
By contrast Pogba made one tackle and two interceptions, and Bruno Fernandes two tackles and one interception.
Pogba made three defensive clearances too, while Matic did not make any.

A position which needs upgrading
Matic plays in a position which United need to address, sooner rather than later.
His new contract was a sticking plaster solution, while United sought to address other positions in the summer.
A report from the MEN this week said the defensive midfield position is one United will be targeting over the next two transfer windows, with it most likely to be solved in the summer.
Matic needs to improve though, because United miss him at his best. If he can find a way to recapture the form he showed between January and July, then it will be a big boost to the club’s ambitions this season.
- Marcus Rashford was England’s best creator, but that is not what Manchester United need him for
- Tyler Fletcher is already seeing the benefits of his World Cup experience in 41-touch Man Utd display
- Forget Tielemans, £117m transfer showed Man Utd sealed the best deal in Premier League in 2025
- Radek Vitek makes clear demand after impressing in Man Utd vs Wrexham, it’s non-negotiable
- JJ Gabriel missed Man Utd vs Wrexham but Carrick didn’t even play two most exciting wonderkids
- Man Utd vs Wrexham showed Carrick can solve his main worry this season by doing what Amorim didn’t
- Kobbie Mainoo’s England injury is one he’s never had before, Thomas Tuchel shares what happened
- Michael Carrick praised Santos and Mount, but three other Man Utd stars should be part of his ‘positives’
- Marcus Rashford makes promise after World Cup that bodes well for Man Utd, JJ Gabriel reacts
- Dan Gore’s electric Man Utd cameo pushes him to the forefront of Michael Carrick’s midfield gauntlet
Receive a digest of our best United content each week direct to your mailbox
