Manchester United’s three worst players against Atalanta

Add as preferred source on Google

Manchester United fought back to scrape a draw against Atalanta thanks to two impressive equalisers from Cristiano Ronaldo.

Ronaldo’s two goals were memorable, but United have plenty to fix if we are to be competitive if we reach the knockout stages.

Along with Ronaldo, Eric Bailly and Bruno Fernandes made our trio of best players from the game.

But it was also a disappointing night, with United’s going behind twice and struggling to create chances until the goals.

Here is a look at three particularly disappointing players…

Paul Pogba

Paul Pogba put in a performance of a player who looked like his mind was elsewhere.

He was unfocused and out of tune with his teammates, struggling to connect with passes, and nearly giving a goal away when dispossessed on the edge of the box.

Pogba completed only 80 per cent of his passes, a very low total by his standards, and lost three out of five duels.

He was fortunate to last as long as he did, and it was a relief when he was substituted on 67 minutes.

Harry Maguire

While Eric Bailly was fantastic, Harry Maguire looked like a liability out there.

Time and time again he was caught out of position, and managed to play Duvan Zapata onside for Atalanta’s second goal.

This was not a performance of a £80 million defender and Maguire needs to sort himself out. Once Raphael Varane went off injured he looked lost.

On this evidence, United’s top defensive partnership should be Varane and Bailly.

Considering the money United spent on Maguire and Pogba, their performances were seriously disappointing.

David de Gea

It hurts to include him here as he has been fantastic this season up until now, but David de Gea had a poor game.

De Gea let Josip Ilicic’s early strike squirm under him and it was a shot he should have saved.

For the second goal he was way too slow off his line, and combine that with a hesitant and slow Maguire and it is a recipe for disaster.

• Youri Tielemans’ past injuries and age cannot overshadow immediate solution solved in Man Utd’s post-Casemiro era
• I was desperate for Man United to sign Eduardo Camavinga, but his latest Real Madrid decision is a worry
• Joshua Zirkzee’s stance on Juventus move could fast-track Man Utd exit
• Danilo has already learned two important skills from Casemiro amid rumblings he could move to Man Utd
• Man Utd may immediately repeat their successful Youri Tielemans ‘trick’ with their next midfield signing
• Why Man Utd’s brand-new Adidas away shirt for 2026/27 Premier League season is in blue design
• Alejandro Garnacho’s Aston Villa spell could determine which of his two ex-Man Utd teammates’ footsteps he follows
• There’s one major difference with how Benjamin Sesko looks in training
• What Manchester United’s XI vs Rosenborg looked like in 2024 pre-season clash
• Unprecedented transfer move: Man Utd swoop for third midfielder would rip up the club’s transfer history
• Michael Carrick’s Chido Obi decision vs Wrexham is puzzling after JJ Gabriel’s inclusion for Rosenborg