Scott McTominay has gone from strength to strength since he left Manchester United to join Napoli.
Manchester United made the decision in 2024 to sell Scott McTominay to Napoli for £25 million, which in hindsight, looks like a terrible deal for the Red Devils.
As an academy product, McTominay’s sale had a huge PSR impact for United, allowing Ineos to spend big on signings.
Scott McTominay HIT OUT at claims United hold players back
What do you think of McTominay's comments? How much he is worth now?
But McTominay went on to win the Serie A MVP and lift the league title with Napoli, all while finding his place on the Ballon d’Or rankings.
Understandably, there is plenty of regret around the decision to sell McTominay, but would United fans have the 29-year-old midfielder back at Old Trafford?
Man United fans vote on re-signing Scott McTominay
Through the Talking Points platform, United in Focus invited our readers to have their say on McTominay’s future.
Would you re-sign Scott McTominay for Manchester United?
Where would he fit in? How much is he worth?
Over 75% of United supporters voted that they would like McTominay to return to Old Trafford, with 25% arguing that he is not what the club currently needs.
One reader wrote: “Scott McTominay coming home would be a great signing for us, especially when as expected Casimero leaves at the end of the season, different type of player I know but come on United he shouldn’t have gone in the first place, he was only sold as it’s 100% profit and Ugarte would be ok to sign, and look how good that went.”
Another added: “Perfect trusted replacement for midfield gap to be caused due to Casemiro departure – no brainer tried tested & Scott is Man Utd throughout.”
However, others made the argument that it would not be the right move: “He loves life in Naples, and we’ve already established he’s more like Bruno than he’s like Casemiro. That’s not the profile we need. Let him enjoy at Napoli.”
“Scott is an attacking midfielder, he is not a ball winner, if caseimro leaves we need a ball winning central midfielder. Scott will give you loads going forward,” Another reader wrote.
Scott McTominay begins contract negotiations at Napoli
Despite being nudged towards the exit door during his time at Old Trafford, McTominay still follows United and supports his childhood club from afar.
But there is no denying that McTominay is loving life in Naples, and Antonio Conte is also a big admirer of him.
READ MORE: Scott McTominay ‘proud’ of Man Utd players after initial run under ‘great guy’ Michael Carrick
According to Football Italia, work is underway to extend McTominay’s contract at Napoli, with his current deal running until 2028.
Reports claim Napoli want to extend McTominay’s deal until 2030, which would no doubt silence rumours of McTominay returning to United.
Receive a digest of our best United content each week direct to your mailbox
