Harry Amass is fighting for a first-team spot at Manchester United while transfer links to Lewis Hall continue to circle.
Manchester United face a decision to trust in academy graduate Harry Amass or to invest in one of the country’s most promising left-backs in Lewis Hall.
Newcastle defender Hall is open to joining United this summer, and the 21-year-old would cost around £60 million this summer, according to TeamTalk.
But United could save those funds and put their faith in Amass, who has impressed in pre-season so far this summer.
If you could only choose one, should Man Utd buy Lewis Hall or promote Harry Amass?
How does Harry Amass compare to Lewis Hall?
United fans were impressed by Amass in the latest 5-0 win over Rosenborg in pre-season. The 19-year-old impressed out on loan at Sheffield Wednesday last season and is now fighting for a spot in Michael Carrick’s squad.
Meanwhile, Hall is already a Premier League-proven star with experience in the Champions League.
United’s faith in youth should lean towards trust being put in Amass, but Hall is a market opportunity that Ineos may feel is too good to turn down.
A statistical comparison from Fbref shows how the two left-backs compare.
| Harry Amass | 2025/26 stats | Lewis Hall |
| 1,881 | Minutes Played | 2,181 |
| 1 | Goals scored | 1 |
| 1 | Assists | 1 |
| 2.25 | Crosses P90 | 4.21 |
| 1.53 | Interceptions P90 | 1.20 |
| 1.91 | Tackles P90 | 1.28 |
Amass and Hall are equally matched in terms of their output. Both defenders managed to score and assist once in 2025/26.
Hall comes out on top in terms of crosses per 90 minutes, but Amass’ defensive numbers stand out with more interceptions and tackles than his competitor.
What is a fair price to pay to sign Lewis Hall?
Do you want Manchester United to pursue a deal?
Man United can redirect Lewis Hall funds
Financially, it is a much better decision for United to trust in Amass next season.
Amass has bulked up to silence any criticism about his physicality, and his loan moves in the Championship have helped him adapt to the demands of men’s senior football.
If United stick with Amass, it will save Ineos the £60m transfer fee on Hall, as well as his wages.
READ MORE: Harry Amass is Man Utd’s Luke Shaw successor, but he is pushing to take over right now
United still need a third midfield signing, potentially a new centre-back and a new striker – especially if Joshua Zirkzee heads for the exit.
Saving on Hall will allow United to spend more on the defence and attack, while also putting faith in a very promising academy graduate.
Receive a digest of our best United content each week direct to your mailbox
