Former Manchester United winger Alejandro Garnacho has signed for Aston Villa.
Alejandro Garnacho has ended his Chelsea nightmare by signing on loan with Aston Villa, who have a conditional agreement to buy.
It is 11 months since Garnacho clinched his £40 million transfer from Manchester United to Chelsea, ending a promising career with the Red Devils.
Garnacho failed to kick on and was part of a deeply flawed Chelsea transfer strategy in 2025 that led to two managers being fired during the season.
Moving to Aston Villa gives Garnacho a fresh start with his career – but supporters are reluctant to believe that the winger will see an uptick in fortunes with his latest move.
What supporters have been saying about Alejandro Garnacho
We looked at the comments on the Talk Villa section on the TalkingPoints app to see what was being said about Alejandro Garnacho. Here is a selection of the responses.
One wrote: “It wasn’t long ago when this guy was United’s latest great hope. What happened here? Is he cursed?”
Another said: “This guy would be at Preston North End if it wasn’t for PSR,” to which another fan responded: “Bit harsh on Preston that. They could do better.”
“I still like my chances of getting a big move if Garnacho keeps doing it, wild!” wrote a fourth.
A fifth added: “Last chance saloon for Garnacho and this is also Emery’s biggest test to date.”
A sixth responded: “Agree with this. If this doesn’t go well for Garnacho then I’m not sure how he can keep falling back on his so called potential.”
Another fan added: “Crazy move from Villa. If Garnacho is the answer I don’t know what the question is.”
A further comment read: “Have they not learned from the Sancho deal?”
But is there hope for Garnacho? One poster believes he could be in for redemption arc.
“Honestly wouldn’t be surprised if he has a great year. The dilemma then becomes what Villa do with him next.”
What is your message to Alejandro Garnacho after he was sold by Chelsea to Aston Villa?
Alejandro Garnacho announced at Villa
Aston Villa announced their deal for Alejandro Garnacho, handing the winger the number 17 shirt.
Manager Unai Emery commented: “We are delighted with Alejandro. He is so talented, young and he showed us his wish to help our project. We are really happy.”
Garnacho looks pleased to be out of Chelsea too. Villa are scheduled to face Manchester United at Old Trafford on November 7.
Receive a digest of our best United content each week direct to your mailbox
