LIVE
...

Follow us on

Transfer News

How Man Utd targets Sandro Tonali and Carlos Baleba compared in head-to-head showdown

Add as preferred source on Google

Manchester United fans got to watch midfield transfer targets Sandro Tonali and Carlos Baleba face each other as Brighton played Newcastle United in the Premier League.

There are as many as 24 midfield targets on Manchester United’s radar heading into the summer transfer window, but Ineos appear to want Premier League-proven talent.

Carlos Baleba and Sandro Tonali both feature high up on United’s shopping list, and they went toe-to-toe as Brighton lost 3-1 to Newcastle United in the Premier League on Saturday afternoon.

Baleba has struggled this season and admits he has been impacted by United’s interest, but his performances have improved in recent weeks.

Carlos Baleba playing against Liverpool
Photo by Chris Brunskill/Fantasista/Getty Images

What is the MAXIMUM you would pay for Carlos Baleba this summer?

After a tough season, how much should Manchester United be risking?

Carlos Baleba playing against Fulham
Photo by Crystal Pix/MB Media/Getty Images

Sandro Tonali vs Carlos Baleba stats analysis

Both Tonali and Baleba started for their respective clubs at St James’ Park on Saturday. Tonali played the full 90 minutes while Baleba was taken off with 10 minutes remaining.

Interestingly, as per SofaScore, both players earned a 7/10 rating for their performance in the match.

Sandro TonaliMatch statsCarlos Baleba
90Minutes played80
45Touches53
77% (23/30)Passes completed89% (32/36)
11Possessions lost8
7Defensive contributions7
3/4Duels won7/12
0Shots attempted2

Despite playing fewer minutes, it is Baleba who dominates most statistical areas with more touches, passes and defensive actions.

Additionally, Baleba took two shots to Tonali’s zero, and the Brighton midfielder struck the crossbar from range with one of his efforts.

How do you really feel about Man United’s Sandro Tonali interest?

Is he who we need in midfield?🇮🇹

FC Barcelona v Newcastle United FC - UEFA Champions League 2025/26 Round of 16 Second Leg
Photo by Image Photo Agency/Getty Images

Carlos Baleba is hitting form just ahead of transfer window

There is no denying that Baleba suffered a poor start to the season, and as a result it seemed that his name dropped down the pecking order of United’s transfer shortlist.

But United are still interested in Baleba and could return to Brighton with an offer this summer.

READ MORE: How much Man Utd would need to sign both Aurelien Tchouameni and Carlos Baleba, compared with Elliot Anderson

His recent performances have been much more like the 2024/25 version of the midfielder that caught United’s attention.

The timing of Baleba’s resurgence is ideal given that the transfer window opens next month. A strong end to the season could be the difference between him calling Old Trafford home next season.