Scott McTominay enjoyed something of a breakthrough season in 2017/18. He was named Manager’s Player of the Year at Manchester United after a campaign that saw him adapt to first team football with diligence and professionalism.
This time around, it hasn’t been so easy for the Scotland international but with United’s midfield floundering, is now the time to bring him back into the fold?
What’s the state of play?
Against West Ham, he played the full 90 minutes in a back three as United went down 3-1 and he was shunted back there against Newcastle before being replaced at half-time, as Jose Mourinho looked to overturn a two-goal deficit.
Mourinho has a habit of playing players out of position to seek to underline his lack of options in a certain role and given his gripes over a lack of a new centre-half in the summer, it looks like that’s what’s happened with McTominay as well.
A promising young talent like him does not deserve to be caught up in a petty power struggle between his manager and board; he has perhaps suffered more than most at United this season as Mourinho’s self-preservation tactics have spiralled out of control.
Should he get back in?United are struggling for control, balance and energy in midfield and the underperformance of Nemanja Matic has been a major issue so far this season.
In terms of style, McTominay is as close to Matic as there is in the Manchester United team right now and if Mourinho wants a tall, imposing, disciplined holding midfield player, then the Scotland man is the ideal replacement.
United fans would love to see one of their own get more first team opportunities and it would freshen up a midfield that is horrendously stale at present.